This seems a perfectly reasonable question to ask for solutions in integers. I cannot find any mention of it - not to say somebody has not considered it.
Consider first x2 + y2/N = b2.
Let z = y / x and w = b / x , giving 1 + z2 / N = w2. This has the obvious solution z=0, w=1.
The line of gradient m through this point meets the quadratic
again at the point
z = 2 m N / ( 1 - m2
N ).
Let m = p / q, and using z = y / x, this gives the
parameterisation of x2 + y2 / N = b2
as
x = q2 - N p2
and y = 2 N p q.
Substitute this into the equation x2 + N y2 = a2, and we get
|
|
This quartic has the clear rational solution h = 0 , g = N , and so is birationally equivalent to an elliptic curve.
We find the family of curves
|
The RHS of EN factors as j ( j - N3 ) ( j - N ( N2 - 1 ) ) so there are 3 finite torsion points of order 2.
If N is a square then there are also 4 points of order 4, but I am unable to prove these are the only torsion points. None of these points lead to a non-trivial solution to the problem so we need EN to have rank at least 1.
As an example, N = 19 has rank 1 with a point
j = 95 * 178032 / 20932
which gives p = 27302 and q = 1961141, leading
to
x = 3831911437005 and y = 2034636720116.
We used the Birch and swinnerton-Dyer conjecture to to predict the rank of the curves for N in the interval [ 2 , 249 ]. The curves with rank > 0 give the results in the file dd8res .
There are currently 8 values of N where we think that
the curve has rank 1, but we are unable to find a generator of infinite
order. The relevant values are given in the following table:
| N | HEIGHT | INFORMATION |
| 177 | 66.2 | |
| 197 | 102.5 | |
| 218 | 113.5 | |
| 173 | 148.1 | |
| 214 | 158.0 | |
| 137 | 185.9 | |
| 163 | 307.6 | |
| 227 | 620.1 |